A confluence of factors is lifting Northwest log prices at a time when U.S. demand for lumber is only expected to grow, timber experts say.
Natural disasters, from wildfires in the West to hurricanes in the South, have restrained the supply of logs from U.S. forests.
Meanwhile, housing construction and remodeling have boosted domestic lumber consumption as Asian buyers continue competing with sawmills for U.S. logs.
Environmental laws that restrict logging on federal lands are unlikely to be relaxed while finding enough workers to harvest and process logs will only get tougher.
The Canadian timber industry, traditionally a major supplier, is unlikely to provide much relief: Timber harvests in British Columbia are declining due to damage from mountain pine beetles while a trade dispute is expected to further limit lumber shipments from that nation.
“The big question for 2018 is if harvest levels should be accelerated, and if so, by how much?” said Mike Mackelwich, vice president of timberland operations for Pope Resources.
Strong prices would indicate that forestland owners are in prime harvest time, but the number of standing trees in the Northwest isn’t infinite.
In the region’s private coastal and inland forests, the harvest level is already reaching the sustainable yield and may exceed timber growth by 2020, said Rocky Goodnow, vice president of North American timber service at Forest Economic Advisors.
During 2017, prices for coastal Douglas fir logs shot up 23 percent from about $650 to more than $800 per thousand board feet, while the price of coastal hemlocks surged 20 percent from roughly $500 to $600 per thousand board feet, he said.
“It’s pointing to the tight supply conditions in the West,” Goodnow said.
Landowners are winning under current circumstances while the profit margins of sawmills are shrinking, said Tim Atkinson, vice president of sales for the Stimson Lumber Co.
At a certain point, mills just have to throw their hands up and stop buying, he said. “You’re already seeing people balk at these situations.”
The demand for lumber from North American mills is projected to increase by about 2 billion board feet a year, reaching nearly 70 billion board feet in 2022, up from roughly 60 billion board feet in 2017, Goodnow said.
Any attempt to escalate logging on public lands will likely be thwarted with lawsuits, he said.
With constricted supplies in the West, this demand is expected to have a big effect in the U.S. South, which is also likely to export more to Asian markets, he said.
“China is going to find the timber where it can,” Goodnow said.
Trade is also expected to affect incoming lumber supplies.
Late last year, the U.S. decided that Canada was subsidizing its timber industry in violation of the Softwood Lumber Agreement, resulting in standard duties on lumber of more than 20 percent, said Atkinson.
Canada is expected to challenge this finding through the World Trade Organization, which may take three to five years to resolve, he said.
The U.S. is expected to “dig in” on its position at a time when the broader trade relationship with Canada is precarious due to negotiations over the North American Free Trade Agreement, or NAFTA, Atkinson said.
Apart from the question of sheer timber supply, U.S. log and lumber production also challenged by labor availability.
“We expect real constraints on the labor side,” said Goodnow.
One factor is the opioid abuse epidemic, which is influencing the decline in labor force participation, he said. “This is hitting the rural communities where the industry is located.”